From Peer to Leader

Promotion

Stepping into a leadership role is a milestone worth celebrating—but it’s also one of the most delicate transitions in a professional career. One day, you’re a peer; the next, you’re setting direction, managing performance, and shaping team culture. The shift from teammate to team leader isn’t just about a new title—it’s about mastering a new mindset.

Why does this transition matter so much? Because new leaders influence culture, retention, and results more than any other role. And yet, many feel unprepared.

According to DDI’s Global Leadership Forecast 2025, over 60% of new leaders say they weren’t ready for the transition, and nearly half fail within the first 18 months. That’s not a reflection of talent—it’s a signal that the right skills and support are missing.

If you’re stepping into leadership, here are four essential skill sets to master—and why they matter now more than ever.

The power couple of effective leadership

Clear communication builds trust. Confidence builds influence. When leaders speak with transparency and decisiveness, teams feel grounded—even in uncertainty.

Yet only 13% of employees strongly agree that their leaders communicate effectively, according to Gallup’s State of the American Workplace4. That gap leads to disengagement, confusion, and mistrust.

What to focus on:

  • Be intentional with your language—what you say and how you say it.
  • Create space for two-way dialogue, not just top-down announcements.
  • Over-communicate during change or ambiguity. Clarity is calming.

Mastering the fundamentals of leadership

The move from peer to leader requires new competencies: setting expectations, holding 1:1s, giving feedback, and managing conflict. These aren’t “nice to haves”—they’re the backbone of daily leadership.

A study cited by Harvard Business Review found that 58% of new managers never receive formal leadership training6. Many are left to figure it out alone, often at the team’s expense.

What to focus on:

  • Structure meaningful 1:1s and team meetings.
  • Use feedback as a growth tool, not just a correction.
  • Be consistent in applying expectations and recognition.

Developing a leadership mindset for long-term success

Great leaders don’t just chase deadlines—they look ahead. Strategic thinking means aligning your team’s efforts with broader goals and building toward sustainable success.

McKinsey’s research shows that 90% of leaders struggle to balance short-term demands with long-term strategy. New leaders often get stuck in task mode, losing sight of growth.

What to focus on:

  • Ask regularly: “Are we working on the right things?”
  • Think about talent development, succession, and team health.
  • Collaborate across departments to widen your lens.

Leading a motivated, accountable team

As a leader, your success is measured by how well the team performs. Creating a culture of shared ownership, mutual respect, and intrinsic motivation is essential.

What to focus on:

  • Use accountability as a form of support, not punishment.
  • Connect team goals to individual motivators.
  • Celebrate progress—not just perfection.

Leadership isn’t about having all the answers—it’s about creating the conditions for others to thrive. From how you communicate to how you plan and motivate, your approach shapes the team’s experience.

Master these four areas, and you won’t just survive the transition—you’ll lead with purpose, clarity, and impact.

MORE BLOG POSTS

Creating a Culture of Strategic Thinkers

For the past 31 years I have worked in local government, most of the time as a manager overseeing the staff, and working with elected councils and boards. Early on …

READ MORE
Make Your Goals a Reality With This Much Needed Self-Retreat

Ready to take some risks?  Commit to this DIY goal-setting self-retreat and you’ll be ready to achieve your goals! The practice of innovation & risk—taking to move you into the …

READ MORE

WOULD YOU LIKE TO SUBMIT AN ARTICLE
to our Leadership Library?